American Consumers Sue World’s Biggest Car Makers Over Deadly Keyless Ignitions

Keyless Ignition

Keyless Ignition


Ten of the world’s biggest carmakers were sued on Wednesday by American consumers who claim they concealed the risks of carbon monoxide poisoning in more than five million vehicles equipped with keyless ignitions, leading to 13 deaths.

According to the complaint filed in Los Angeles federal court, carbon monoxide is emitted when drivers leave their vehicles running after taking their electronic key fobs with them, under the mistaken belief that the engines will shut off.

The 28 named plaintiffs said this can injure or have “deadly” results for people who inhale the colourless and odourless gas, including when vehicles are left in garages attached to homes. They also said the defect reduces their vehicles’ resale values.

A keyless ignition lets a driver start a vehicle by pushing an on-off button, instead of inserting a key, once the vehicle senses the presence of a nearby electronic fob.

The defendants include BMW, including Mini; Daimler’s Mercedes Benz; Fiat Chrysler; Ford Motor Co; General Motors Co; Honda, including Acura.

Also named as defendants were Hyundai, including Kia; Nissan, including Infiniti; Toyota, including Lexus; Volkswagen, including Bentley.

The lawsuit is the latest seeking to hold the automotive industry liable for defects that could make driving unsafe, such as Takata airbags and ignition switches on GM vehicles.

It claimed that the 10 carmakers have long known about the risks of keyless ignitions, which have been available in the US since at least 2003, yet deceived drivers by marketing their vehicles as safe.

The plaintiffs said the carmakers could have averted the 13 deaths, and many more injuries, by installing an inexpensive feature to automatically turn off unattended engines, and that GM and Ford even took steps to patent a shut-off feature.

They also said 27 complaints have been lodged with the national highway traffic safety administration (NHTSA) since 2009.

“The automakers had actual knowledge of the dangerous carbon monoxide poisoning consequences of vehicles with keyless fobs that lack an automatic shut-off,” the complaint said.

Unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning kills about 430 people a year in the US, says the Centres for Disease Control and Prevention.

The lawsuit seeks class-action status, and an injunction requiring car-makers to install automatic shut-off features on all existing and future vehicles sold with keyless ignitions. It also seeks compensatory and punitive damages.

Ford said it takes customer safety “very seriously” and that its keyless ignition system has proven “safe and reliable”.

BMW, Fiat Chrysler and Toyota declined to comment. None of the other carmakers had an immediate comment.

Lawyers for the plaintiffs also declined to comment. A US transport department spokesman declined to comment on the NHTSA’s behalf.

The lawsuit was filed in the same court where Toyota defended lawsuits claiming that its vehicles accelerated unintentionally.

A US district judge, James Selna, approved a $1.6bn settlement in July 2013 to resolve claims that Toyotas lost value because of that defect. It is unclear whether he will be assigned the keyless ignition case.